American restaurants

Toad's Burger Bar

4.8 113 reviews Closed 25 Main St, Poultney, VT 05764, United States

Discover this place

Toad's Burger Bar, located at 25 Main St, Poultney, VT, is a haven for burger enthusiasts and casual diners alike. Its reputation is built on serving some of the best smash burgers in the area, drawing comparisons to iconic chains like In-N-Out. The atmosphere is welcoming, with friendly staff providing attentive service, as noted by patrons like Glenn Berntson, who enjoyed watching the chef work their magic at the grill while savoring a juicy burger with bacon and Toad's signature fries. The diverse menu at Toad's offers more than just burgers; from crispy chicken wraps to fried pickles and the unique cheesecake egg roll, there's something to entice every palate. Bobby C praises the fantastic food and reasonable prices, while Sniper_Assasin emphasizes the milkshakes, claiming they deliver a delightful, ice-cream-like richness that's hard to find elsewhere. Every review resonates with a common theme: the exceptional quality of dishes and the vibrant, friendly atmosphere. Whether you're stopping by for a late lunch or a full meal with friends, Toad's Burger Bar promises a satisfying experience that will have you coming back for more.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Outdoor seating
Takeout
Dine-in
Delivery

Highlights

Fast service
Great beer selection
Great cocktails
Serves local specialty
Sports

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner
Counter service
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities

Bar onsite
Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual
Cozy

Crowd

Family-friendly
Groups
Tourists

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Toad's Burger Bar before visiting.

Reviews for Toad's Burger Bar

4.8

113 reviews

100%

12%

Review highlights

Based on 113 reviews

Toad's Burger Bar in Poultney, VT, consistently receives praise for its flavorful, well-seasoned burgers and classic American fare that resonates with both locals and visitors. Reviewers frequently highlight the fresh, satisfying taste of the smashed burgers and the quality of the sides, particularly the fries. The atmosphere is described as welcoming, with a lively bar setting that allows guests to engage with the chefs and enjoy a casual dining experience. Service is commonly noted as attentive and friendly, enhancing the overall visit. Patrons also appreciate the reasonable pricing and well-crafted beverages, including chilled beers and indulgent milkshakes, which complement the robust menu offerings. Overall, Toad's Burger Bar is recognized for combining great food, drink, and ambiance in a relaxed, neighborhood-style environment.

Glenn Berntson

Jul 27, 2025

I dropped in for a late lunch and ate at the bar. The service was delightful. Nice conversation, very helpful, and I had a cold beer in a matter of moments. Sitting at the bar was extra special because the grill was right there. I got to watch the good bring made and talk to the chef as they were cooking. Neat! I had a burger with cheese and bacon, and the Toad's fries. This isn't health food. This is delicious food. The burger was hot off the griddle - and terrific.

Bobby C

Jul 25, 2025

Absolutely one of the best burgers I’ve had in a while. Fantastic food and service! Very good prices!

Sniper_ Assasin

Jul 20, 2025

This place is like the local’s In & Out— absolutely PERFECT smash burgers seasoned like they were made at a family outing, beer served in a chilled glass that makes you smile, and milkshakes any food-lover will stand by. Most other places you’re looking at underseasoned food and a milkshake that tastes like it was made by some nutritionist hell-bent on calorie-cutting other lads— BUT THIS JOINT? Nah… that milkshake is made thick, creamy, and the same flavor as you’d get spooning some ice cream out of the carton. Absolutely love Toad’s, and I will certainly be returning for more.

Linda P

Jul 16, 2025

Amazing burgers and fries! Definitely our go to when we’re in the area.

Haley Billow

Jul 13, 2025

Great burgers! Great Service! Great atmosphere! We were so happy to stumble upon Toad’s while desperately searching for an open restaurant within 30 minutes of our NY AirBnB. So worth the drive!

Kristin Meberg

Jun 01, 2025

Omg! If you're in the area, you HAVE to stop in to this amazing burger place. The burgers are delicious!!! Toppings are fresh, bacon is crisp and the buns definitely stand up to the 4 pattie burger!!!! Highly recommend their chocolate milkshake. Staff was very friendly and welcoming. We ordered inside and ate outside. Tables were nice and clean. The game room is definitely a cool addition. We will be back to check out it out. The game room has seating to eat while you catch up on the game.

Jason Szumlanski

May 18, 2025

Burgers were a SMASH! Hehe . Seriously, this place is a great little find. Nice beer list, full liquor bar, pool table, and fun atmosphere. Dude on the griddle was working hard and making magic.

Erika Joy

Apr 11, 2025

The wings are really good! Loved the hot honey sauce. Garlic parm fries are always a good choice and I also really liked the steak and cheese sandwich! Burgers are also great Basically you can’t go wrong. It’s also super affordable too!